![]() ![]() The central question at the end of the novel is “who is guilty?” Is Wargrave guilty because he killed ten people? Or was he only following his duty as a servant of the law? Did the guests of Soldier's Island deserve their fate, were they guilty enough to deserve death no matter what? These answers depend on the reader's highly subjective understanding of guilt. For example, Anthony Marston thinks that he ran over those children accidentally so it doesn't matter – everyone has their own way to cope with guilt. The guests on Soldier's Island have been able to survive for so long with their own guilt because they come up with various definitions of right and wrong to pardon themselves. Both of these characters show how guilt can be defined by one's own personal moral and legal system. Her understanding of guilt is similar to Wargrave's understanding of justice: Brent believes that she is not guilty because she killed a sinning woman, and Wargrave believes that he can cause ten murders if it is in the name of justice. Brent's solid belief in God, and her belief that she is always in God's good graces, means that she is incapable of feeling guilty. In chapter 10 of And Then There Were None, Emily Brent finds the words 'The Murderer's name is Beatrice Taylor' written in her notebook.She does not know whether she wrote the words herself or. Through Miss Emily Brent, the novel also presents a religious view of guilt. 7) Lyrics After breakfast, Emily Brent had suggested to Vera Claythorne that they should walk up to the summit again and watch for the boat. Agatha Christie demonstrates that guilt is not only doled out by a jury, but rather, like justice, it is a complicated concept that involves human flaws and inconsistencies. 2 Contributors And Then There Were None (Chap. For example, General Macarthur wishes death upon himself because he cannot handle his guilt-ridden any longer and Vera is constantly plagued by dreams and visions of the little boy she killed for the man she loved. Agatha Christie, on the other hand, shows that the self-inflicted punishment that comes from personal guilt is often even more painful than any sentence given by the law. Wargrave cannot stand that these people have not been declared guilty by a court of law. ![]() Yet he does not believe that a sense of personal guilt is enough. Justice Wargrave understands the power of personal guilt as shown by the fact that he guesses Vera will kill herself when she is the last one left on the island. The majority of the characters in the novel are people who have escaped the latter but are plagued by the former. And Then There Were None presents two kinds of guilt: personal and legal.
0 Comments
Leave a Reply. |
AuthorWrite something about yourself. No need to be fancy, just an overview. ArchivesCategories |